Retrofitting Apple CarPlay/Android Auto: Original Screen vs Replacing the Screen

If you’re considering upgrading your car with Apple CarPlay or Android Auto, you might be wondering whether to retrofit the system into your original screen or replace the screen entirely. Both options have their advantages and drawbacks. Understanding these can help you make the right choice for convenience, cost, and aesthetics.

What is Retrofitting Apple CarPlay/Android Auto?

Retrofitting refers to integrating CarPlay or Android Auto into your existing infotainment system without replacing the original screen. This can involve using an interface module or adapter that allows your car’s stock screen to communicate with your smartphone.

Replacing the screen, on the other hand, involves installing a new aftermarket infotainment system that comes with built-in support for Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.

Option 1: Retrofitting Into the Original Screen

Pros:

1. Preserves the Original Look: Your dashboard keeps its factory appearance, which is ideal for classic or high-end vehicles.

2. Lower Installation Impact: Typically requires less invasive installation, as the original wiring and dashboard components remain intact.

3. Maintains OEM Features: Functions like climate controls, steering wheel buttons, and vehicle-specific menus often continue to work seamlessly.

4. Potentially Cheaper: The cost of a retrofit module is often lower than buying a full replacement infotainment system.

Cons:

1. Compatibility Issues: Not all car models support retrofitting; some may require complex wiring or programming.

2. Limited Functionality: Some retrofit modules only support basic CarPlay/Android Auto features, not advanced options like split-screen navigation or high-resolution graphics.

3. Possible Latency: The interface may introduce slight lag or delayed responses compared to a fully integrated system.

4. Hidden Installation Complexity: Even though it keeps the original screen, certain modules require professional installation to work properly.

Option 2: Replacing the Screen

Pros:

1. Full Modern Features: Aftermarket systems usually support the latest Apple CarPlay and Android Auto features, including wireless connectivity, full-screen navigation, and enhanced media playback.

2. Better Performance: Dedicated hardware ensures smoother responsiveness and faster updates.

3. Customizable Options: You can choose a screen size, resolution, and even additional features like built-in GPS, DVR, or enhanced audio processing.

4. Future-Proofing: Easier to upgrade in the future as new software versions are released.

Cons:

1. Higher Cost: Aftermarket screens with full CarPlay/Android Auto support can be expensive, especially when factoring in installation.

2. Aesthetic Changes: The new screen may not match the original dashboard design, which can look out of place in certain cars.

3. Potential Loss of OEM Features: Some vehicle-specific functions, like steering wheel controls or parking sensors, may not integrate perfectly with aftermarket units.

4. Complex Installation: Replacing the screen often requires significant disassembly and professional installation to avoid wiring or system conflicts.

Which Option is Right for You?

• Keep the Original Look & OEM Functionality: Go with a retrofit module if you want a subtle upgrade without changing your dashboard’s appearance.

• Maximize Features & Performance: Replace the screen if you want the latest CarPlay/Android Auto experience, larger displays, and smoother operation.

• Budget-Conscious: Retrofitting is usually cheaper upfront.

• Tech Enthusiast: A new screen provides a more “future-proof” solution for long-term usability.

Final Thoughts

Upgrading to Apple CarPlay or Android Auto can dramatically improve your driving experience, whether through hands-free navigation, voice commands, or seamless media access. Choosing between retrofitting your original screen and replacing it depends on your budget, priorities, and car model.

If you want to preserve the classic feel of your dashboard and avoid major modifications, retrofitting is a smart choice. But if you’re after cutting-edge features and full integration, a screen replacement is the way to go.